US courtship of Venezuela tests Guyana’s border guarantee
Washington has moved to reassure Guyana that it still backs the 1899 award fixing its border with Venezuela, after a Reuters report that a Trump administration official had floated ceding part of Essequibo, two-thirds of Guyana’s territory, to Caracas.
“The position on the land border between the two countries has not changed. The United States reaffirms its support for the 1899 arbitral award,” the State Department said in a written statement to EFE on November 19. The award “must be respected unless - or until - a competent legal body or the consent of both parties establishes a new boundary,” it added.
The wording is firmer than the department’s first response to Reuters. That said only that it was “pitched different ideas and policy options from outside parties every day” and that its position was unchanged. Yet it still leaves a door ajar. A border set by “the consent of both parties” is the bilateral deal Caracas has long sought. Georgetown, however, refuses to discuss one while the International Court of Justice (ICJ) weighs the award’s validity.
For Guyana the stakes go to the core of the state, as Essequibo – a region rich in natural resources including gold, diamonds and bauxite – lies next to the offshore fields that have made Guyana the world’s fastest-growing economy, according to the IMF, since ExxonMobil’s first discovery in 2015.
Reuters reported on November 19 that Jeremy Lewin, then the State Department’s director of policy planning, met Guyana’s foreign secretary, Robert Persaud, in Washington in September. He told Persaud he could help broker territorial talks with Venezuela’s acting President, Delcy Rodriguez. Two people familiar with the matter told the agency that Lewin floated Venezuela taking partial control of Essequibo.
Lewin, a former employee of Elon Musk’s DOGE, took up the post in August and left at the end of October. He did not say what he had proposed, but confirmed that he had held talks with both sides on the White House’s instructions. Rodriguez wrote to US President Donald Trump in May seeking mediation and raised the matter with Lewin in Caracas in July. “The White House asked me to conduct preliminary and confidential conversations with the Guyanese and Venezuelans to better dimension the issue for the Administration,” Lewin told Reuters.
Guyana’s foreign ministry said the September meeting had focused on the pending ICJ ruling and that “Guyana has received the assurance of the US Government that nothing has changed since”. It did not address the reported suggestion that it give up land. President Irfaan Ali ruled out any compromise over Essequibo in January, even if Washington asked for one. That came days after US forces captured former president Nicolas Maduro and Rodriguez, his vice-president, took over in Caracas.
On November 20 Rodriguez restated Venezuela’s position, a rare point of consensus in a deeply polarised country, without naming Washington. “Venezuela reaffirms its historical position of rejecting the fraudulent 1899 arbitration award, as well as its non-recognition of the International Court of Justice to resolve the territorial dispute over the Essequibo region,” she said on her official Telegram channel, according to El Universal.
She urged Georgetown to respect its “inescapable obligations” under the 1966 Geneva Agreement and settle the dispute “through negotiations satisfactory to both parties”. “No country can try to evade its international obligations by relying on third parties or external bodies incompatible with its pre-existing obligations,” she added. Caracas had already renewed its call for direct talks with Georgetown in October.
Washington, meanwhile, is courting both capitals. Rodriguez spent years as one of the Maduro regime's most combative critics of the US, but she swung towards Washington almost as soon as she took power, opening up Venezuela’s oil industry to foreign investors, as the White House demanded, and turning the country into what analysts describe as a de facto US protectorate. On November 18 Pete Hegseth, the US defence secretary, signed a military co-operation agreement with her in Caracas. A month earlier he and Ali had agreed a defence partnership at the Pentagon, the latest step in a security relationship that has deepened since Guyana’s oil boom began.
The legal case is in its final stage. Guyana asked the ICJ in 2018 to confirm the award. The court ruled in 2020 that it had jurisdiction and rejected a further Venezuelan objection in 2023. In May, Venezuela told the court that the award was a colonial-era fraud and that the Geneva Agreement requires a negotiated settlement. Hearings on the merits closed on May 11 and no date has been set for judgment. Ali expects one early next year.
The court has twice ordered interim measures at Guyana’s request. The latest, in May 2025, barred Caracas from holding elections in the territory. Venezuela under then-president Maduro went ahead anyway and elected a “governor” for the state it calls Guayana Esequiba from a specially drawn district on its own side of the border.
The award Washington now defends was itself a product of US pressure. In July 1895, Secretary of State Richard Olney invoked the Monroe Doctrine to force Britain to put its frontier quarrel with Venezuela to arbitration. “Today the United States is practically sovereign on this continent, and its fiat is law,” he declared, as the historian Leslie Bethell recounts in a 2024 paper for CEBRI-Journal, the review of the Brazilian Center for International Relations in Rio de Janeiro.
Under the 1897 Treaty of Washington the US represented Venezuela. American lawyers, among them former president Benjamin Harrison, argued its case in Paris. On October 3 1899 the five judges unanimously awarded British Guiana about 95% of the disputed territory west of the Essequibo river and gave Venezuela the mouth of the Orinoco.
Venezuela accepted the outcome for six decades. In 1962, as Britain prepared to grant British Guiana independence, then-president Romulo Betancourt declared the award null and void. He relied on a memorandum by Severo Mallet-Prevost, a junior lawyer on the US team, which was published after his death in 1949. It alleged a backroom deal between the tribunal’s Russian president and the British judges. Mallet-Prevost offered no evidence and his claims were never corroborated, Bethell writes.
The 1966 Geneva Agreement, signed three months before Guyana’s independence, gave a mixed commission four years to find a settlement acceptable to both sides. Bethell calls it “an agreement to reach agreement”. The commission failed. In 1982, Venezuela declined to extend a 12-year moratorium agreed in Port of Spain in 1970, but the dispute then stayed largely dormant until Exxon’s oil discoveries in 2015 raised the stakes. In December 2023 Maduro, who was deeply unpopular and whose 2018 re-election the US and dozens of other governments had refused to recognise, staged a referendum on annexing the region in a bid to rally Venezuelans round the flag.
Today, as Venezuela scrambles to revive its ailing oil industry with US help after Maduro’s removal, investment continues to pour into its small but resource-rich neighbour. ExxonMobil operates the Stabroek block, which lies off the Essequibo coast in partly disputed waters, with a 45% stake. Chevron, through its acquisition of Hess, holds 30%, and China’s state-owned CNOOC holds 25%. The block’s first four projects passed 1bn barrels of cumulative output in September. The start of a fifth, Uaru, this month is expected to lift production above 1mn barrels a day. On November 12, the partners approved Longtail, a $12.5bn development that is the block’s eighth project and its first aimed at gas rather than oil. Two more, Whiptail and Hammerhead, are due to start production in 2027 and 2029.
“Guyana will never voluntarily give up Essequibo, especially now that it is oil rich,” Bethell wrote.
Follow us online